Legalbrief
  Subscriber login (email address):
Tue 09 February 2010

Advanced Search

Home Pages

Legalbrief Today
Legalbrief Judgments
Legalbrief Africa
eLaw & Management
Legalbrief Forensic
Legalbrief Environmental

For Your Info

About Legalbrief
Vision & Mission
Quotations & Subscriptions
Advertise with Us
Contact Us
Terms & Conditions

Specialist Sections

Financial Supplement
Legal Links
Events Calendar










This site is updated Monday to Friday by 9.00am




  


Pikoli cleared by Ginwala Commission
Published in: Legalbrief Africa
Date: Mon 10 November 2008
Category: South Africa
Issue No: 306



Suspended national prosecutions boss Vusi Pikoli could be back at work as early as this month as former National Assembly Speaker Frene Ginwala has cleared him of government claims that he was not a 'fit and proper' person for his position. A summit of southern African leaders had told Zimbabwe's rival parties they should share control of the disputed Home Affairs Ministry.

But, while recommending that Pikoli be reinstated to his former job, Ginwala is understood to be critical of him, finding that he was not sensitive to national security and other interests when making prosecutorial decisions. A Cape Times report says she was also less than complimentary about the Justice Department, particularly director-general Menzi Simelane, whose evidence sought to paint Pikoli as a renegade who took the National Prosecuting Authority's independence too far. While finding that there was some basis to the government's claims that Pikoli's relationship with former Justice Minister Brigitte Mabandla had deteriorated, Ginwala had concluded that these problems were not enough to justify permanently axing him. Insiders say Pikoli is likely to resign if he is reinstated, having challenged his suspension in order to clear his name and reveal the facts behind his controversial suspension.
Full Cape Times report (subscription needed)

A confidential ANC report has slammed former President Thabo Mbeki's suspension of Pikoli, saying the action was both 'opportunistic' and 'unsubstantiated'. The scathing report, drafted by law firm Garlicke and Bousfield, concluded that Pikoli was suspended only after arrest and search warrants were obtained against Police Commissioner Jackie Selebi and that there were 'no reasons' to suspend him. A Sunday Times report says the firm was briefed by ANC secretary-general Gwede Mantashe in June to perform a watch over the Ginwala commission of inquiry. It was to 'consider and advise on issues that may affect the interest' of the ANC.
Full Sunday Times report




  

'Legalbrief

Supported by the IBA


Legalbrief Africa Links
About Legalbrief Africa
News Categories
Newsletter Archives
Subscribe


Register for a free subscription to Legalbrief AFRICA, sponsored by the International Bar Association


Related Links
About Legalbrief Africa
More on South Africa
Newsletter Archives
Other articles in issue 306