Myths about East Africa’s people movement unhelpful
Publish date: 16 November 2026
Issue Number: 1203
Diary: IBA Legalbrief Africa
Category: Immigration
Migration from east Africa and the Horn of Africa is often incorrectly portrayed as a journey towards Europe, writes Girmachew Adugna, advisory board member, Research Centre for Forced Displacement and Migration Studies, Addis Ababa University, in an analysis in The Conversation. He says international news reporting typifies it as the mass movement of people from Ethiopia, Eritrea or Somalia, transiting through Sudan, Libya and the Mediterranean to reach Europe. ‘But the truth is that people would rather move closer to home: within the region, Gulf states and southern Africa. Around 87% of the 8.5m international migrants in east Africa and the Horn of Africa come from within the region. They move for work, family, education, trade, security and other reasons. The perception that traffic mostly heads north comes from popular misconceptions – migration myths. Narratives matter because they shape people’s understanding of the world, and even government policies.’ Adugna states that often overlooked in dominant migration narratives are the voices and lived experiences of migrants and their communities, whose complex realities are frequently reduced to statistics. ‘One of the most persistent assumptions in migration policy is that east African countries are primarily places from which people leave. Yet the region is also a major destination for migrants and refugees. The UN Refugee Agency’s 2026 data shows Uganda hosts about 2.05m refugees and asylum seekers, followed by Ethiopia with 1.02m, Sudan with 910 000 and Kenya with 879 000. This means migration is a regional system of mobility, in which people move in multiple directions and for multiple reasons. Policies built around a simple origin-transit-destination model can fail to capture what is often a process rather than a single journey.’
Adugna feels that another common narrative is that poverty and climate change are the main reasons people leave east Africa. ‘They certainly matter. But the reality is more complicated. People also migrate because of family and social networks, labour demand elsewhere, insecurity and political instability. They also go in hope of a better future or are driven by established cultures of migration. Somali, Eritrean and Ethiopian diaspora communities, for example, can provide information and financial support to relatives and friends seeking to migrate. The relationship between poverty and migration is not straightforward. Migration to Europe is more expensive than routes towards the Gulf or South Africa. The cost of travelling from Ethiopia to Europe through the northern route is estimated at around $10 000. The southern route costs about $4 800 and eastern routes to the Gulf cost about $700. People need resources and networks to migrate, particularly along expensive routes.’ Adugna notes in The Conversation analysis that human smugglers and traffickers feature prominently in migration policy. ‘East African and European governments all point to this as the main reason people migrate irregularly. They talk of preventing exploitation, disrupting smuggling networks and managing irregular migration. This view has helped channel a disproportionate share of migration programming and interventions at the expense of other forms and destinations. But this can obscure other factors. Interviews for my research indicate that limited livelihood opportunities and the absence of accessible legal migration pathways can encourage people to use irregular routes. In some communities, migration brokers are not perceived only as criminals. In parts of southern Ethiopia, for example, brokers have been described as “door openers” because they facilitate access to opportunities elsewhere. This local perception should not be confused with an endorsement of smuggling. Migrants using these networks can face serious exploitation, abuse and deception. But it does help explain the persistence of smuggling.’
Adugna believes that migration research in the region has paid relatively little attention to intra-African migration. ‘This can create a feedback loop. The issues that receive funding are researched. Those findings then inform policy. Policy creates new programmes around the same issues, generating more data and research. The evidence base can become too focused on Europe-bound migration. He states in The Conversation analysis that governments and international organisations need better data on movement within the continent. ‘Policy initiatives should also shift to providing local opportunities for young people. They should aim to expand legal avenues for labour migration for both skilled and semi-skilled migrants. This should be paired with stronger oversight of recruitment agencies to prevent corruption, fraud and exploitation. Co-operation between countries of origin, transit and destination should also go beyond border controls and the return of migrants. It should include protecting workers’ rights, holding exploitative recruiters accountable and ensuring that migrants can seek help when things go wrong. Finally, migration policy designed without the migrants’ perspectives risks solving a problem that looks very different on paper from the one people experience in reality. Their experiences should inform migration policy and programmes.’